Khalil Faaed: Are We Measuring the Sperm That Actually Matter in DNA Fragmentation Testing?
Khalil Faaed, Embryologist at Modern IVF Center, shared on LinkedIn:
“We keep measuring sperm DNA fragmentation, but are we measuring the sperm that actually matter?
Sperm DNA fragmentation (SDF) has become an important parameter in the evaluation of male reproductive potential.
But conventional SDF measurements generally consider the sperm population as a whole.
And this raises an important biological question:
Does DNA fragmentation in a dead sperm carry the same clinical meaning as DNA fragmentation in a viable sperm?
Probably not.
A sperm sample is not a uniform population. It contains viable and non-viable sperm, and these populations may have very different biological relevance.
This is where viable sperm DNA fragmentation (viable SDF) becomes particularly interesting.
Instead of asking only:
How much DNA fragmentation is present in the sample? we can ask:
How much DNA fragmentation is present specifically among the sperm that remain viable?
Technically, this approach combines sperm viability assessment with DNA fragmentation analysis, allowing viable sperm to be distinguished from non-viable sperm during the analysis.
The distinction can be substantial.
- A high total SDF value may partly reflect DNA damage in sperm that are already non-viable.
- Conversely, a relatively low total SDF could potentially mask a clinically relevant level of DNA fragmentation within the viable sperm population.
This does not mean that viable SDF has already replaced conventional SDF or that it is definitively a superior predictor of pregnancy or live birth.
Rather, it introduces a more biologically focused question:
Are we measuring DNA damage in the entire sperm population or are we measuring DNA integrity in the sperm population that still has reproductive potential?
The recent cross-sectional evidence suggesting that viable SDF may provide additional diagnostic information is therefore worth watching closely.
The next step is prospective validation:
Can viable SDF better predict fertilization, embryo development, blastocyst formation, implantation, clinical pregnancy, and live birth?
Perhaps the future of sperm DNA assessment will not simply be about measuring how much DNA is damaged.
It may also be about understanding which sperm carry that damage and whether those sperm are still viable.
The question may no longer be only ‘How fragmented is the sperm DNA?’
It may become:
‘Whose DNA is fragmented and does that sperm still matter?’”

Other articles featuring Khalil Faaed on Fertility News.
-
Nov 22, 2026, 17:01Insights from ISFP 2026
-
Nov 22, 2026, 16:17Khalil Faaed: The Dark Center of the Oocyte
-
Nov 22, 2026, 16:10Jyoti Gupta: Proud to Join Cloudnine Fertility, Golf Course Road, Gurugram, as Director
-
Nov 22, 2026, 15:45Francine Freitas Fernandes: 3D and 4D Hysterosalpingo-Contrast Sonography
-
Nov 22, 2026, 15:25New RBMO Study Links Microfluidic Sperm Sorting to Higher Blastocyst Formation and Lower Miscarriage Rates
-
Nov 22, 2026, 15:21Michelle Mason: Pleased to Attend the Annual SWIGS Conference with the Care Fertility Cardiff Team
-
Nov 22, 2026, 15:18Rajeev Agarwal: The Lining Is 6.5 mm – Will the Embryo Transfer Fail?
-
Nov 22, 2026, 15:11The Automated IVF Laboratory Lecture by Jacques Cohen at the 5th Narture – Conceivable Life Sciences
-
Nov 22, 2026, 15:07Laura Rienzi: Same Message, 2 Slides – Which One Would You Rather See at a Congress?
