NewsFeed
November, 2026
November 2026
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  
Rajeev Agarwal: An Open Tube Is Not Always A Working Tube
Nov 16, 2026, 19:22

Rajeev Agarwal: An Open Tube Is Not Always A Working Tube

Rajeev Agarwal, Director of Renew Healthcare, shared on LinkedIn:

” ‘My HSG is normal. So why am I not pregnant?’

I hear this every week.

As a keyhole (laparoscopic) surgeon, I often see what a dye test cannot.

An HSG answers one question: are the tubes open? But an open tube is not always a working tube.

The three tests, simply:

  1. HSG (X-ray dye test): shows if the tubes are open, and the shape of the womb.
  2. Foam scan (HyFoSy): shows if the tubes are open, with less pain. It gave the same answer as HSG in about 3 out of 4 women.
  3. Laparoscopy (keyhole surgery): lets me see the tubes, scar tissue and endometriosis directly.

What the research shows:

  • In women with ‘unexplained’ infertility who had a laparoscopy, more than 4 in 10 had endometriosis, mostly mild.
  • In one large trial, an oil-based dye for HSG was followed by more pregnancies than a water-based dye.

What I do:

  • I don’t offer laparoscopy to everyone.
  • I do offer it when the story points to the pelvis: painful periods or painful sex, a past pelvic infection or surgery, or a normal HSG and still no pregnancy after months of well-timed trying.
  • In India, I also test for TB when the tubes look abnormal.

What to ask your doctor:

  1. What can my test not see?
  2. Given my history, do I need a laparoscopy?

Choose the test for the question.”

Rajeev Agarwal

Other articles featuring Rajeev Agarwal on Fertility News.