Aumatma Simmons: How Common Is It for a 1st IVF Cycle to Fail?
Aumatma Simmons, Co-Founder and Chief Medical Officer at Madre Fertility, shared on LinkedIn:
”A failed first IVF cycle is treated by many patients as a personal failure.
Statistically, it’s closer to the expected outcome.
Success rates per cycle vary by age: approximately 40-50% under 35, 30-40% at 35-37, 20-30% at 38-40, and 10-20% over 40. Even in the best-case scenario, roughly half of first cycles do not result in a live birth. Requiring multiple cycles is the norm, not the exception.
What matters more than the failure itself is what caused it, and whether that gets investigated before the next attempt.
Commonly overlooked contributors include:
- Sperm DNA fragmentation, not captured in a standard semen analysis
- Undiagnosed thyroid antibodies affecting implantation
- Chronic inflammation affecting egg quality or endometrial receptivity
- Vaginal or uterine microbiome imbalances
- Nutrient deficiencies affecting embryo development
This is the distinction that matters most: patients who go into a second cycle with the same protocol and the same unaddressed unknowns are repeating what didn’t work the first time.
Patients who investigate and address root causes before cycle two, or even before starting their first cycle, enter with meaningfully better odds.
A failed cycle should prompt investigation, not just repetition.”

Other articles featuring Aumatma Simmons on Fertility News.
-
Oct 26, 2026, 17:12Dilpreet Banwait: Could Our IVF Laboratory Consumables Be Introducing Microplastics into Sperm Samples?
-
Oct 26, 2026, 17:05Yashpal Singh Rao: IVF Care Should Adapt to Patients’ Lives, Not Expect Patients to Adapt
-
Oct 26, 2026, 16:57Zeinab Kazemianpour: Fresh or Frozen Embryo Transfer
-
Oct 26, 2026, 16:52Sean Lauber: IVF Birthweights Catching Up to the General Population
-
Oct 26, 2026, 16:43Sanketh Dhumal Satya: The S Value Paradox – The Curious Case of Sperm Size
-
Oct 26, 2026, 16:25Laura Rienzi: My Lab in 2012 – GENERA Center Was Born
-
Oct 26, 2026, 16:08Mina Popovic: Last Week I Had the Pleasure of Giving Two Talks at the 9th ART Fertility Conference
-
Oct 26, 2026, 16:04Rajeev Agarwal: “Unexplained” Infertility – 3 Numbers Worth Knowing
-
Oct 26, 2026, 16:01Margaret Cali: Dear Brave Soul, a Gentle Reminder for This Week
